Peanutt Butter is a beautiful, brazen and bold woman. She is privileged and knows what she wants. At least she thinks she does. Then she meets and begins dating Trey Stanley, a family orientated teacher whose dedication is only match by his sensitivity and compassion towards the women in his life. The situation spirals out of her control when she accidentally falls for the sexy, successful yet egotistical Sinclair Lawrence. She finds the best of both worlds in two very different men. Now Peanutt Butter is torn when she has to ultimately choose between the two.